Mobile Devices in the Classroom: The Debate Rages On

As I have evolved as a technology teacher I have had to make peace with many issues. I am not a "digital native" and marvel at antiques and simple ways of life. So I often have a conflict of my beliefs when it comes to discussing mobile devices in the classrooms.

In the article, "Mobile Tech in the Classroom Boosts English Learners, http://www.google.com/reader/view/?hl=en&tab=wy#stream/feed%2Fhttp%3A%2F%2Fpeople.uis.edu%2Frschr1%2Fet%2F%3Ffeed%3Drss2 middle school students demonstrate how mobile devices, like iTouch and Smartphones can help students remain engaged and productive in the classroom. I had several "ya, but" questions to ask. Much to my surprise there was an answer to most of them.

Here is the first one, "Ya, they are great and kids love them, BUT what if a family is struggling financially and can't afford a device. The article says students shared them and worked collaboratively. Hum, group work, isn't that a skill we want students to improve.

Next, Ya, they are helping English Language Learners keep up with studies, BUT what about the security issue. And this is a big one. Security for the equipment and security for the students. This is probably one of the biggest hurdles that must be jumped. Most administrations have strict restrictions for the use of mobile devices in school. I personally hate seeing students sitting in the hallway texting and listening to what ever during school hours. BUT this article provided and outline about the strict guidelines that were implemented in order for mobile devices to be used IN THE CLASSROOM.

So my strong reservations for using mobile devices in the classroom really has nothing to do with using these tools, but everything to do with how they can be used outside the classroom and the problems that can arise. I want to use iTouch in a math class this year but for my own sake I am going to have all my ducks in a row, (the lesson planned) and my permission slips signed and approved by administration and parents, and probably students as well. Then I think I can sleep better at night....

Thanks for listening,
Anne